GRUMPY DAD
CARDS
Wishlist
🏈 INDIANAPOLIS COLTS

Peyton
Manning

QB
8
Cards in binder
$0.25
Starting at
/999
Rarest print
SHOP ALL 8 CARDS ↓
★ RAREST ·
Peyton Manning card
BEST CARD
Peyton Manning card
BEST CARD
Peyton Manning card
Team & checklist cards

LANDSCAPE CARDS

Peyton Manning 2025 Panini Prizm Black
Peyton Manning
2025 Panini Prizm Black
$0.25
😤
📣 DAD’S TAKEON PEYTON MANNING

Look at this guy waving like he's the grand marshal of some parade! Manning's out here making Netflix documentaries about quarterbacks while posing like he's saying goodbye to his mom at summer camp. That goofy wave and dopey smile – no wonder he's better behind the camera than he ever was avoiding pass rushers!

ABOUT PEYTON MANNING

Oh man, Peyton Manning, now there's a legend for you. This Colts quarterback was absolutely elite during his prime, one of those cerebral field generals who could pick apart any defense. What's really cool is how his influence crossed sports boundaries, even inspiring players like Caitlin Clark who grew up wearing his jersey despite being a Chiefs fan. Manning's got that rare combination of incredible talent and widespread respect that makes his cards consistently popular with collectors. Since he doesn't have true rookie cards from his playing days, his early parallels and numbered inserts tend to carry the premium that rookies usually get.

These days, Manning is greeted like royalty wherever he goes – even at the homes of former division rivals. Though his Colts routinely torched the Bills, the Hall of Fame quarterback was warmly received when he toured Buffalo's facilities during an offseason visit. He even took a picture with head coach Sean McDermott.

— 2025 MOSAIC

Manning built a Hall of Fame career leading a potent offense with the Colts. He guided the team to a title at Super Bowl XLI, was tabbed a First Team All-Pro five times and snagged four MVP awards during his time in Indianapolis. His 54,828 yards and 399 touchdowns are the most in franchise history.

— 2025 DONRUSS

No player in NFL history was ever more valuable to his team than Manning. And he has the hardware to prove it. The Hall of Fame quarterback set a record by winning league MVP honors an incredible five times. He won with Indianapolis in 2003, '04, '08 and '09 and with Denver in 2013.

— 2025 DONRUSS ELITE

Manning has put up Hall of Fame numbers during his illustrious career, including multiple MVP awards and Pro Bowl selections. Known for his incredible football IQ and preparation, Manning has been one of the most dominant quarterbacks in NFL history. His leadership and clutch performances have made him a fan favorite in Indianapolis.

— 2025 PRIZM BLACK

Peyton put in countless hours of work after practice to make everything he did between the white lines look easy. He won four of his five league MVPs with the Colts and led the franchise to a title in Super Bowl XLI. Manning's 71,940 yards and 539 touchdowns were both league records at the time he retired.

— 2025 CHROME

Think of the best No. 1 overall pick of all time. ESPN.com, using writer Ben Solak to blend a combination of "most talented" and "most successful" for the team picking them. Manning, understandably, got the nod as the lead pick in the 1998 NFL Draft, by the Colts. He won a championship and altered a franchise's fortunes.

— 2025 ROOKIES & STARS

OTHER INDIANAPOLIS COLTS DAD’S HOARDING

Riley Leonard
Riley Leonard
Quarterback · 15 cards
→
Tyler Warren
Tyler Warren
TE · 25 cards
→
JT Tuimoloau
JT Tuimoloau
Defensive End · 9 cards
→
Jonathan Taylor
Jonathan Taylor
Running Back · 19 cards
→

FREQUENTLY ASKED — PEYTON MANNING CARDS

Which Peyton Manning cards sell the most frequently?

As of March 10th, 2026, there are over 5,184 Peyton Manning cards listed on eBay. Listings range from $0.99 to $650, with an average price around $70.96. That includes rookie cards averaging $86.08, autographs ranging from $149 to $2,500, numbered parallels averaging $31.04.

Listing data reflects current eBay activity and is updated regularly.

How are Peyton Manning's card prices and popularity trending?

As of June 19th, 2026, Peyton Manning's card market is active with 5,184 listings on eBay. Current listings range from $0.99 to $650, with an average around $70.96. Numbered parallels are averaging $31.04.

Pricing reflects current eBay listing data and is updated on a regular schedule.

What is Peyton Manning's most expensive card?

The highest-priced Peyton Manning autograph cards currently listed on eBay reach up to $2,500. Autographed cards range from $149 to $2,500. Numbered parallels range from $1.48 to $170. Base cards start around $0.99.

Values based on current eBay listings as of March 10th, 2026.

Are Peyton Manning cards a good investment?

Card collecting involves risk, and past performance doesn't guarantee future returns. Here's what the data shows for Peyton Manning:

Peyton Manning's card market is active with 5,184 listings on eBay. There are 2,334 autographed cards available on eBay ranging from $149 to $2,500. Numbered parallels (107551 listed) average around $31.04 and tend to hold value better than base cards due to limited supply. Base rookie cards start around $0.99, making them an accessible entry point.

Grumpy Dad Cards provides market data for informational purposes. We're card collectors, not financial advisors.