ROOKIE CARD
⚾ BOSTON RED SOX
Payton
Tolle
P
9 Payton Tolle cards in Dad’s binder from 5 sets: 2026 Topps Cosmic Chrome, 2026 Bowman, 2026 Topps Holiday, 2026 Topps Finest and 2026 Topps Series 2. That includes 8 rookie cards and 2 serial-numbered cards.
9
Cards in binder
$1.50
Starting at
/150
Rarest print
★ RAREST · /150
BEST CARD
BEST CARD
Every card we’ve got
PAYTON TOLLE CARDS IN THE BINDER
Base, parallels, numbered, autos: every Payton Tolle card Dad’s willing to part with.
ROOKIE CARD
ROOKIE CARD
Payton Tolle
$7.00
ROOKIE CARD
Payton Tolle
$3.00
ROOKIE CARD
ROOKIE CARD
ROOKIE CARD
Payton Tolle
$1.75
ROOKIE CARD
😤
📣 DAD’S TAKEON PAYTON TOLLE
Three cards from a pitcher whose professional career lasted barely over a year before appearing on cardboard in multiple premium releases. The Finest uncommon treatment and the Stars of MLB designation arrived fast, packaging eight debut strikeouts into instant collectibility. That Dynamic Duals pairing feels like filler when one half of the duo just got here. At least the debut stats hold up to scrutiny.
ABOUT PAYTON TOLLE
Payton Tolle is a left-handed pitcher for the Boston Red Sox, born November 1, 2002, in Stillwater, Oklahoma. He was drafted by Boston in the second round of the 2024 MLB Draft from Texas Christian University. Tolle had spent one season at TCU after transferring from Wichita State, where he was a two-way player. He signed with the Red Sox and climbed through three minor league levels in 2025, recording a 3.04 ERA with 133 strikeouts over 91 and two-thirds innings. Tolle made his MLB debut on August 29, 2025, against the Pittsburgh Pirates. He became the first Red Sox pitcher to record eight-plus strikeouts in his MLB debut since Daisuke Matsuzaka in April 2007.
This collection includes three 2026 Payton Tolle cards representing his rookie and sophomore campaigns. The Topps Series 2 Stars of MLB insert and the Finest Base Uncommon both commemorate his impressive debut performance. The Dynamic Duals base card captures him alongside another player in a set celebrating baseball's signature pairings.
MORE BOSTON RED SOX CARDS DAD’S HOARDING
MORE FROM 2026 TOPPS SERIES 2
FREQUENTLY ASKED: PAYTON TOLLE CARDS
What is the most valuable Payton Tolle card in Dad's binder?
The 2026 Cosmic Chrome Purple Nebula Refractor #115 numbered 115/150, at $97.
What is the rarest Payton Tolle card in Dad's binder?
The 2026 Cosmic Chrome Purple Nebula Refractor #115 numbered 115/150.
Does Dad have Payton Tolle rookie cards?
Yes. 8 rookie cards: 2026 Cosmic Chrome Purple Nebula Refractor #115; 2026 Cosmic Chrome Aqua Equinox Refractor #115; 2026 Cosmic Chrome #115; 2026 Bowman Base Chrome Rookie Red RC Logo Variation #26; and 4 more.
How much do Payton Tolle cards cost here?
9 Payton Tolle cards here, from $1.50 to $97. The cheapest is the 2026 Bowman Mojo Refractor #26.