Tyrann Mathieu
2023 Panini Donruss Optic
Shield27/32
$43.00
🏈 NEW ORLEANS SAINTS
Tyrann
Mathieu
SAFETY
2
Cards in binder
$1
Starting at
/32
Rarest print
★ RAREST · /32
BEST CARD
Every card we’ve got
THE TYRANN MATHIEU COLLECTION
Base, parallels, numbered, autos — every Tyrann Mathieu card Dad’s willing to part with.
Tyrann Mathieu
2025 Panini Prizm
$1.00
😤
📣 DAD’S TAKEON TYRANN MATHIEU
Look at this guy posing like he's about to ask me if I want to upgrade my oil change to synthetic. That scraggly facial hair and the way he's standing there all cocky – he looks more like he should be working at a vape shop than playing safety. And don't get me started on how he's probably still telling everyone about that one interception from Week 5 like it's his claim to fame.
ABOUT TYRANN MATHIEU
Oh man, Tyrann Mathieu is such a cool story for collectors. This guy's a Louisiana legend through and through, starred at LSU and bounced around the league with Arizona, Houston, and Kansas City before coming home to the Saints in 2022. He's been incredibly consistent as a playmaker, picking off at least three passes in each of his first three seasons back in New Orleans. What makes his cards interesting is that he doesn't have traditional rookie cards since he entered the league later, so his early stuff from Arizona tends to carry more premium. Look for his Saints cards now since the hometown angle really resonates with collectors, and any numbered parallels or autographs are solid pickups.
Born and raised in New Orleans and a standout at LSU, Mathieu is a Bayou State legend. After stints in Arizona, Houston and Kansas City, the safety returned to Louisiana when he signed with the Saints in 2022. Feeling at home, the Mathieu logged at least three interceptions in each of his first three seasons there.
— 2025 PRIZM
A scrappy safety who plays with confidence, Mathieu sparks the New Orleans defense with his aggressive play. He set the tone for the Saints with a pick-six early in the first quarter of their Week 5 shutout vs. New England. That marked his first interception of the 2023 season and the 30th of his career.
— 2023 DONRUSS OPTIC
OTHER NEW ORLEANS SAINTS DAD’S HOARDING
FREQUENTLY ASKED — TYRANN MATHIEU CARDS
Which Tyrann Mathieu cards sell the most frequently?
As of March 30th, 2026, there are over 672 Tyrann Mathieu cards listed on eBay. Listings range from $1.40 to $89.95, with an average price around $13.08. That includes rookie cards averaging $42.70, autographs ranging from $11.99 to $395, numbered parallels averaging $18.84.
Listing data reflects current eBay activity and is updated regularly.
How are Tyrann Mathieu's card prices and popularity trending?
As of June 19th, 2026, Tyrann Mathieu's card market is active with 672 listings on eBay. Current listings range from $1.40 to $89.95, with an average around $13.08. Numbered parallels are averaging $18.84.
Pricing reflects current eBay listing data and is updated on a regular schedule.
What is Tyrann Mathieu's most expensive card?
The highest-priced Tyrann Mathieu autograph cards currently listed on eBay reach up to $395. Autographed cards range from $11.99 to $395. Numbered parallels range from $0.99 to $79.99. Base cards start around $1.40.
Values based on current eBay listings as of March 30th, 2026.
Are Tyrann Mathieu cards a good investment?
Card collecting involves risk, and past performance doesn't guarantee future returns. Here's what the data shows for Tyrann Mathieu:
Tyrann Mathieu's card market is active with 672 listings on eBay. There are 152 autographed cards available on eBay ranging from $11.99 to $395. Numbered parallels (2124 listed) average around $18.84 and tend to hold value better than base cards due to limited supply.
Grumpy Dad Cards provides market data for informational purposes. We're card collectors, not financial advisors.